The Nigeria Democratic Congress is demanding a forensic audit of ₦11.2 trillion in NNPCL receivables, accusing the Tinubu administration of prioritising opaque spending over military security. But the audited accounts reveal a more complicated financial picture, raising fresh questions about oil revenues, government deductions and public accountability.
Nigeria’s growing security crisis has exposed an uncomfortable question about the management of public money: how can billions of naira be difficult to account for in military procurement while trillions of naira in petroleum-related receivables remain poorly explained?
The question has gained fresh political significance following a statement by the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC), which has challenged President Bola Tinubu’s administration over ₦11.2 trillion recorded in the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited’s (NNPCL) audited financial statements as other receivables from the Federation.
The party alleges that the figure represents an opaque pipeline-security expenditure arrangement which dwarfs Nigeria’s defence budget, even as soldiers face shortages of modern equipment and communities continue to experience kidnappings, killings and attacks.
But a closer examination of NNPCL’s financial disclosures reveals an important distinction that changes the interpretation of the controversy.
The ₦11.2 trillion is a balance-sheet receivable, not proof that the company paid that amount to pipeline-security contractors in 2025. It combines advances to the Federation and costs associated with protecting oil and gas assets. The published accounts do not separately identify how much belongs to each category.
That distinction does not eliminate the accountability problem. It makes transparency even more important.
The central question is no longer simply how much Nigeria spends protecting its petroleum infrastructure. It is whether Nigerians can establish exactly what the money represents, who received it, what services were delivered and how the government authorised the transactions.
The ₦11.2 trillion question: What NNPCL actually disclosed
NNPCL’s 2025 audited financial statements, published on its investor relations platform, provide the basis for the controversy.
According to Note 24.2, the company’s receivables from the Federation stood at approximately ₦11.20 trillion at the end of December 2025, compared with ₦17.51 trillion recorded in 2024.
The breakdown is particularly important.
Other receivables from the Federation increased from ₦8.84 trillion in 2024 to ₦11.20 trillion in 2025, representing an increase of approximately ₦2.36 trillion, or 26.7 per cent.
NNPCL explained that the category covers advance payments to the Federation and costs incurred in protecting Nigeria’s oil and gas assets.
The company’s financial statements state:
“Other receivables from the federal government relate to advance payments to the federation and the security costs incurred in protecting the oil and gas assets.”
The report also explains that the arrangement operates under an approved framework between the Nigerian Government and NNPCL.
According to the company:
“This is under the framework of approval between the Government of Nigeria and the Group to incur security costs and charge the same to the Federation.”
These disclosures establish that security-related expenditure forms part of the receivables. They do not establish that the entire ₦11.2 trillion was spent on pipeline protection.
More importantly, NNPCL has not provided a sufficiently detailed public breakdown showing how much represents advances, how much relates to infrastructure protection and how much was paid to individual contractors.
That missing information is central to the controversy.
The accounting distinction that changes the controversy
There is another important issue within NNPCL’s financial disclosures that deserves attention.
The term energy security costs also appears in the company’s earlier financial statements, but it does not necessarily mean pipeline surveillance or armed protection of petroleum infrastructure.
NNPCL’s 2024 audited accounts explain that its energy-security expense included under-recovery arising from the difference between the actual landing cost of imported Premium Motor Spirit (PMS) and the regulated selling price.
The company’s accounting policy states:
“The under recovery is essentially the difference between the actual landing cost of the product and the regulated price.”
This is the accounting treatment associated with the petrol price differential historically borne by NNPCL on behalf of the Federation.
In 2024, NNPCL recognised approximately ₦7.13 trillion in energy-security expenses.
Its 2025 accounts subsequently disclosed that it recognised no new energy-security expense during that financial year.
The company stated:
“During the year, no energy security expense was recognised (2024: ₦7.13 trillion).”
It further explained that the outstanding ₦8.67 trillion energy-security receivable from the previous year was reconciled with relevant government agencies and netted against royalties, taxes and dividends due to the Federation.
That reconciliation was concluded in September 2025.
Consequently, two different accounting issues must not be confused: the earlier petrol under-recovery balance and the 2025 other receivables covering advances and security costs associated with protecting oil and gas assets.
Treating the ₦11.2 trillion as a single pipeline-security expenditure obscures these distinctions.
It also risks turning a legitimate financial accountability investigation into an inaccurate interpretation of the accounts.
What the Petroleum Industry Act allows
The legal framework surrounding NNPCL’s operations also deserves scrutiny.
Section 64(m) of the Petroleum Industry Act 2021 provides for NNPCL to act as a supplier of last resort for security reasons, with associated costs borne by the Federation.
The legislation states that the company may be required to:
“make NNPC Limited supplier of last resort for security reasons and all associated costs shall be for the account of the Federation.”
This provision provides a statutory context for certain costs charged to the Federation.
It does not, by itself, establish that every amount recorded under other receivables is properly incurred, correctly calculated or adequately documented.
NNPCL’s reference to an approved government framework for oil and gas asset protection therefore raises further questions.
Where is the framework?
Which government authorities approved it?
What are the rules for selecting contractors, determining contract values and verifying completed services?
How are payments reconciled with the Federation’s revenue accounts?
And what independent mechanisms establish that the reported expenditure represents actual services delivered rather than unverified financial claims?
The existence of a statutory responsibility should not become a substitute for public accountability.
Indeed, where the financial burden ultimately falls on the Federation, taxpayers and citizens have a legitimate interest in understanding how the money is committed and accounted for.
The defence budget comparison: A troubling disparity, but not an equivalent comparison
The NDC argues that the ₦11.2 trillion receivable exceeds twice Nigeria’s entire ₦4.91 trillion defence and security allocation for 2025.
It also places the figure against the approximately ₦3.10 trillion allocated to the Ministry of Defence.
The arithmetic is broadly correct.
₦11.2 trillion is approximately 2.28 times the ₦4.91 trillion defence and security allocation and approximately 3.6 times the Ministry of Defence’s ₦3.10 trillion allocation.
But there is an important financial qualification.
The NNPCL figure is a balance-sheet amount outstanding at the end of 2025. The defence figures represent annual budget appropriations.
One is an outstanding receivable; the other is an authorised spending allocation for a financial year.
They cannot automatically be treated as equivalent expenditure.
Nevertheless, the comparison draws attention to a genuine question about Nigeria’s security priorities: whether spending on military capability, intelligence, surveillance and equipment is receiving sufficient attention.
The 2026 Appropriation Act provides further evidence of the pressure on defence resources.
The Ministry of Defence received approximately ₦3.158 trillion.
Of this amount, approximately ₦2.393 trillion was allocated to personnel costs, while capital expenditure received approximately ₦466.3 billion.
That means personnel costs account for approximately 75.8 per cent of the ministry’s allocation, while capital expenditure represents about 14.8 per cent.
The remaining allocation covers overhead costs.
The figures suggest limited financial space for capital investment, although an appropriation does not automatically establish how much money was actually released or spent.
The controversial 7 per cent military funding claim
The NDC also alleges that only 7 per cent of the 2025 Defence Capital Budget was released.
The claim deserves investigation, particularly given the scale of Nigeria’s military and public safety challenges.
However, publicly reported Open Treasury figures require a more precise interpretation.
A Daily Trust investigation published in April 2026 reported that the Nigerian Army received just ₦1.46 billion of the ₦20.56 billion budgeted for the purchase of security equipment in 2025.
That represented 7.11 per cent of that particular budget line.
The same investigation found that only ₦16.71 billion of the ₦336.76 billion earmarked for the Army’s purchase of defence equipment was disbursed, representing 4.96 per cent.
However, the Army’s overall expenditure performance was reported at 25.94 per cent, while the Nigerian Air Force recorded 19.04 per cent.
These figures point to serious funding and execution problems, particularly in equipment procurement.
But they do not establish that only 7 per cent of the entire Defence Capital Budget was released.
The distinction matters because a specific equipment allocation is not the same as the entire capital budget of the defence establishment.
The NDC’s broader argument about inadequate military equipment funding therefore has supporting evidence, but its blanket 7 per cent figure requires a clearly identified budget-wide denominator and official release records.
Is the ₦11.2 trillion a political patronage fund?
Perhaps the most explosive allegation in the NDC statement is its suggestion that the expenditure arrangement amounts to a political patronage operation disguised as energy security.
The party asks:
“Are patronage pay outs to political allies now worth more than Nigerian lives?”
It further describes the arrangement as a potential:
“massive political patronage slush fund disguised as ‘energy security’.”
These are serious allegations.
Yet the published financial disclosures do not, on their own, establish that the money was diverted to political allies or that contractors received payments without delivering services.
The NDC has not supplied a contractor-by-contractor breakdown, payment vouchers, beneficiary records or documentary evidence demonstrating that the ₦11.2 trillion represents political patronage.
That does not make the allegations irrelevant.
It means they must be investigated rather than treated as established findings.
A credible investigation should establish the identities of the contractors, the value and duration of each contract, the services delivered, the payment dates and the officials who authorised the expenditure.
It should also establish whether any sums were duplicated, improperly classified or deducted without the necessary approvals.
The NNPC accounts provide a starting point, not the conclusion of such an investigation.
The forensic audit Nigeria needs
The NDC has made three principal demands.
First, it wants an immediate forensic audit of the ₦11.2 trillion NNPCL receivable, including disclosure of payments to private contractors and outstanding legacy obligations.
Second, it wants full disclosure of military capital releases and troop welfare funding for 2025 and 2026.
Third, it wants an end to off-budget deductions, insisting that oil revenues should enter the Federation Account and remain subject to National Assembly appropriation.
These demands raise questions that the government and NNPCL should address with documentary evidence.
A meaningful independent examination should establish:
- The precise division of the ₦11.2 trillion between advances and oil-asset security costs.
- The complete list of contractors, contract values, payments and services delivered.
- The government approvals and reconciliation records supporting the expenditure.
- How the receivables were treated against royalties, taxes and dividends due to the Federation.
- Actual defence equipment and operational funding releases compared with approved appropriations.
The government should also explain how its security expenditure translates into measurable improvements in military capability and the protection of petroleum infrastructure.
NNPCL’s financial reporting is an essential starting point, but a balance-sheet disclosure is not a substitute for a transparent public expenditure trail.
The politics of accountability ahead of 2027
The NDC’s intervention also carries an unmistakable electoral dimension.
The party urges Nigerians to support the Peter Obi and Rabiu Kwankwaso presidential ticket, arguing that the country needs a government that works for everyone rather than a privileged few.
Its statement concludes:
“The Obi/Kwankwaso ticket believes that Nigeria must work for all, and not a few.”
This political appeal places the NNPCL controversy within the wider debate over the Tinubu administration’s economic management, security policy and public expenditure priorities ahead of the 2027 general election.
But accountability should transcend party politics.
An opposition party should be expected to substantiate allegations of corruption and patronage with evidence. Equally, an administration controlling public resources should not expect citizens to accept unexplained financial claims simply because they appear in audited accounts.
The government must demonstrate that money committed to protecting national assets produces measurable results.
The real scandal may be what Nigerians cannot see
Nigeria needs to secure its pipelines. Oil theft, vandalism and disruptions to petroleum production threaten government revenue, energy supply and economic stability.
There is no credible argument for abandoning that responsibility.
But the need to protect oil infrastructure cannot justify an inadequate explanation of billions or trillions of naira charged to the Federation.
Nor can the scale of Nigeria’s security crisis excuse weak military procurement, delayed capital releases or insufficient investment in modern surveillance and intelligence systems.
The most important question emerging from the ₦11.2 trillion disclosure is not whether oil infrastructure should receive protection.
It is whether the Nigerian government and its national oil company can show, transaction by transaction, what the money represents.
The NDC has demanded a forensic audit. The figures justify serious scrutiny, even though its political-patronage allegation remains unproven.
Ultimately, Nigerians should not have to choose between securing the country’s oil wealth and protecting the people whose lives depend on the state.
Both responsibilities are essential.
And neither should be financed through an accounting system that leaves citizens struggling to establish where their money went.
Follow us on our broadcast channels today!
- WhatsApp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VawZ8TbDDmFT1a1Syg46
- Telegram: https://t.me/atlanticpostchannel
- Facebook: https://www.messenger.com/channel/atlanticpostng




Join the debate; let’s know your opinion.